Review: Midnight In Paris

Woody Allen’s best film in years sees the New York-born writer-director create a cinematic love letter to Paris with Owen Wilson doing his best Woody impression.

midnight in paris, woody allen film,

Woody Allen’s love letter to Paris is not the first cinematic incarnation of that cherished piece of prose, and it surely won’t be the last. But as an American “tourist” lavishing rose-tinted (and golden hued) praise on the mid-19th century neo-classical stone buildings and labyrinthine cobbled streets of Paris’ various arrondissements, Midnight In Paris may well be the best. The film is like a great big hug enveloping everything from the Place de la Concorde to Montmartre, The Palace of Versailles, Sacre-Coeur, and Champs-Elysees. Indeed, Allen begins the film with a protracted montage set against the music of jazz musician Sidney Bechet. It sees the Manhattan-director’s camera move around the city capturing its grand architecture and the people that inhabit it like a hundred live-action postcards ready to send home. Allen is telling us there’s something special about this place, and we are about to find out why.

Owen Wilson plays Gil Pender, an easily distracted American writer vacationing in Paris with his fiancée’s parents. Partner Inez (Rachel McAdams) throws scorn on Gil’s romanticised view of the city as he tries to use the holiday as inspiration for a novel he is struggling to finish. After taking an evening stroll he is picked up by an antique car and finds himself transported back to the 1920s. He encounters his idols such as F. Scott Fitzgerald and Ernest Hemingway who encourages him to take his unfinished novel to the renowned American writer Gertrude Stein. Subsequently, at midnight on each of the following evenings, Gil finds himself in the golden era of the 1920s, inhabited by the great artists, writers, filmmakers and musicians he adores and draws influence from in his work and his life. It is here that he begins to fall in love with Pablo Picasso’s muse Adriana (Marion Cotillard). These nightly jaunts create suspicion in Inez’s father who has a private detective follow his future son-in-law, while Gil and Inez’s relationship becomes more and more insufferable.

“Midnight In Paris is the affectionate creation of a dreamer who desperately wants to meet his own influential icons.”

On meeting Ernest Hemingway, Gil tells him his novel is about a nostalgia shop. This is fitting for Midnight In Paris which sees writer-director Allen at his most wistful. Crucially, however, the film’s sentimentality never becomes overbearing, with Allen displaying a genuine and heartfelt thirst for some of his own artistic heroes as envisaged through Owen Wilson’s Gil. From Hemingway to Picasso to the likes of T.S Elliott, Salvador Dali, Luis Bunuel, and even Edgar Degas, Midnight In Paris is the affectionate creation of a dreamer who desperately wants to meet his own influential icons. It is a wonderful conceit imbued with a longing but considered approach by Allen. He beautifully uses it as a time-travelling adventure story as well as philosophical forum for discussion on literature, art, historical relevance, love, sexuality, and identity that brilliantly brings us back to the present.

midnight in paris, film review, woody allen,

What holds Midnight In Paris back from being regarded alongside Allen’s greatest achievements – Manhattan, Annie Hall, Hannah and Her Sisters, The Purple Rose of Cairo – comes down to his fictional characters. Rachel McAdam’s Inez is far too obnoxious making you wonder why mild-mannered Gil ever fell in love with her. Despite her obvious beauty, Gil doesn’t appear the type to put up with her constant belittling or parent’s who consider him a communist. And while Owen Wilson does a great impression of Woody Allen circa 1980, you know who is pulling the strings. It takes something away from the authenticity of Gil, despite him being an otherwise intriguing character who is trying to find direction in mid-life.

“It is elegantly photographed as if everyone, whether inside or out, is lit by the glow of a roaring rustic fireplace”

Yet, Midnight In Paris is the best work Woody Allen has done in a long while. He bares his soul through the real life men and women he idolises in a film that smartly exudes sentimentalism without the schmaltz. It is elegantly photographed as if everyone, whether inside or out, is lit by the glow of a roaring rustic fireplace, jauntily scored by another run out of the Woody Allen Jazz Collection, and acted with the sort of vigour you expect when actors get the chance to work with Allen’s verbose dialogue. Stand outs come from the small parts – Adrien Brody playing Salvador Dali and Michael Sheen as Inez’s pseudo-intellectual friend Paul, obviously have a lot of fun. The ever-reliable Kathy Bates plays Gertrude Stein and Marion Cotillade is enchanting as Gil’s 1920’s love interest.

But Paris is the star of show, and while Allen rejoices in bringing such famous figures as Picasso and Ernest Hemingway to life, the heart of the film is the city. For these ninety minutes at least, the New York-born writer-director and maker of so many loving portraits of his home town, has found a second love. A love he recreates with beauty, humour, and a sense of hope.

Review by Daniel StephensSee all reviews

Woody Allen coverage on Top 10 Films:
Top 10 Woody Allen Lists by: Julia Kukiewicz | Jose Solis | Alex Withrow
Top 10 Undervalued Woody Allen Films (by Anthony Nield)

Directed by: Woody Allen
Written by: Woody Allen
Starring: Owen Wilson, Rachel McAdams, Marion Cotillard, Kathy Bates, Adrien Brody, Carla Bruni, Michael Sheen
Released: 2011 / Genre: Comedy/Romance/Fantasy / Country: USA/Spain / IMDB
Buy on DVD:
Amazon.co.uk: DVD
More reviews: Latest | Archive

About the Author
Editor of Top 10 Films, Dan Stephens is usually found pondering his next list. An unhealthy love of 1980s Hollywood sees most of his top 10s involving a time-travelling DeLorean and an adventurous archaeologist going by the name Indiana.

Related Posts

  1. Raghav Modi Reply

    Real nice and quite detailed review. Glad you enjoyed it as much as I did.

  2. Steve Aldersley Reply

    Good review. I’m glad you enjoyed it. I like the classic Woody Allen titles, but I would put Midnight in Paris and Vicky Cristina Barcelona right up there with his best. Good point about Gil’s relationship with Inez.

  3. Castor Reply

    Nicely written Dan. Glad you finally got to see what this was all about 😉 Yes, the characters are very much your typical Woody Allen archetypes but it’s whimsical and wraps up before you ask yourself too many questions. Overall, one of the most pleasant movie of the year!

  4. Thomas Reply

    somebody has to do it… tell the world that Woody Allen these days does embarrassing movie versions of reader’s digest tourist guides. This is all so clumsy! every cliche is used, and none in an original way. of course “Midnight” is not half as terrible as “Vicky, Christina..”, but still I found it hard to bear, especially with the almost creepy effort to clone the Woody Allen character through a different actor. Creeped me out in “Whatever Works”, annoyed me to death here. I know, I am the only person in the world who so much dislikes Allen films these days, but I so much hope that he comes up with something interesting again! 🙂
    http://thomas4cinema.wordpress.com/2011/12/28/midnight-in-paris-woody-allen-2011/

  5. Dan Reply

    @Raghav: thank you.

    @Steve: yeah, although it isn’t perfect it is delightfully charming and that papers over the few cracks.

    @Castor: as per usual I took my time finding out what the hype was all about. I’m just glad the film lived up to it.

    @Thomas: your reaction to Midnight in Paris appears similar to mine in regards to Match Point.

  6. Claire Reply

    Great write up, Dan. I’m so glad you enjoyed this film – it was the only one last year that I saw twice at the cinema!

    I do agree with you in regards to Gil and Ines. I wondered what he ever saw in her as well 😛

  7. Rodrigo Reply

    Glad to hear you enjoyed Midnight in Paris. From all the current BP candidates, I wish this one could win the whole thing. However, that seems unlikely to happen.

  8. The Focused Filmographer Reply

    I really loved Midnight in Paris and claimed it as my #1 fave of last year (of those I got to see). But, I must say that you are correct in Inez’s character (played by Rachel McAdams). She was a bit too obnoxious and oblivious to the quirks of Wilson’s character.

    Great review and I am glad that you got to see it and have it delight you so.

Leave a Reply

*